Plainsong


Band members               Related acts

- Ian Matthews -- vocals, guitar

- Dave Richards --

- Andy Roberts -- 

- Bob Ronga --

 

 

 

- Fairport Convention (Ian Matthews)

- Ian Matthews (solo efforts)

- Matthews Southern Comfort (Ian Matthews)

 

 

 


 

Genre: rock

Rating: 3 stars ***

Title:  In Search of Amelia Earhart

Company: Elektra

Catalog: EKS 75044
Year: 1972

Country/State: UK

Grade (cover/record): NM / NM

Comments: cut lower left corner; gatefold sleeve

Available: 1

GEMM catalog ID: 5447

Price: $35.00

 

I'

 

"In Search of Amelia Earhart" track listing:
(side 1)

1.) 

 

(side 2)
1.) 

 

 

A quartet formed by Ian Matthews in 1972 with Andy Roberts, Bob Ronga, and Dave Richards. They released In Search of Amelia Earhart the same year to critical praise but little commercial success. While working on their follow-up, the more country oriented Plainsong III, Ronga quit and Matthews and Richards were unable to agree on the direction the band would take musically. They disbanded before the album's completion. In 1993, a revived interest in the band inspired a new studio album, Dark Side of the Room, as well as a BBC recording of a promotional tour from 1972. In 1994, the band released Voices Electric. Sister Flute followed in 1996. In 1997, Clive Gregson (ex-Any Trouble, Gregson & Collister) joined the band, with New Place Now appearing two years later.

 

In just under three years, Ian Matthews split from Fairport Convention, went solo, formed Matthews' Southern Comfort - with whom he scored a number one U.K. hit - left the group at the height of its popularity, recorded three more records on his own (only two were released at this time) and in early 1972 started Plainsong, his fourth band in five years. And while his track record led one to believe that Plainsong may be just another short stay, the subsequent album, In Search of Amelia Earhart, proved to be worth the venture. Ian Matthews was of course the obvious draw, but Plainsong seemed to be formed as more of a collective effort, with lead guitarist Andy Roberts, who shares the lead vocal duties, the other focal point in the band. On the other hand, Matthews, whose folk and country-tinged tunes set the tone for the record, is the only member to contribute original material. Included among these is the thematic "True Story of Amelia Earhart," which along with the haunting "For the Second Time," leads a pack of five Matthews compositions that range from good to excellent. Elsewhere, Paul Siebel's heartbreaking "Louise," the dulcimer and harmony driven Appalachian gospel of "I'll Fly Away," and Roberts' readings of the playful "Yo Yo Man," Jim & Jesse's "Diesel on My Tail" and the mournful 1939 tale of "Amelia Earhart's Last Flight" are all highlights. Its title and artwork, along with notes by Charles Goerner on the flight and disappearance of Amelia Earhart and Frederick Noonan, gave In Search of Amelia Earhart the feel of a concept album, even though the title is nowhere to be found on the outside jacket and there are only two songs related to the subject contained within. It wasn't really a surprise when a follow-up, though recorded, failed to materialize, with the band parting ways on less than amicable terms, and Matthews going on to record two more records for Elektra. Still, In Search of Amelia Earhart fits nicely alongside the rest of his terrific early-'70's catalogue.

 

 

by 1972 Ian Matthews played in four different incarnations within three years. He’d left Fairport Convention for his own band, Ian Matthews Southern Comfort, put out two solo LPs for Vertigo Records, and then started the band Plainsong.

It is probably fair to say that Plainsong - In Search Of Amelia Earhart is the pinnacle of his work in the ’70s. Working with producer Sandy Robertson (Hard Meat, Steeleye Span, Shirley Collins), Ian and bandmates, notably Andy Roberts who shared vocals on the album ,created an a-typical British folk album conceived around the idea of the legends surrounding Amelia Earhart and her supposed demise.

Matthews had read a book by Fred Goerner hypothesizing that Earhart and her flying companion Frederick Noon had crashed around the Japanese held Marshall Island area and been taken prisoner by the Japanese on Saipan, in the Marianas, in 1937.

Their plane had supposedly been outfitted with aerial cameras and had a bigger fuel tank than anyone outside of the US government knew. After being grilled by Japanese interrogators Earhart would perish of dysentery, and Noonan was beheaded by the Japanese.

Supposedly:

...a grave containing remains of a man and a woman were excavated by the US military on Saipan after the war in the Pacific was over. These bodies were thought to be Earhart and Noonan. Earhart's plane Electra was found in a hangar on the island in 1945. On the highest orders it was rolled out, drenched in gasoline and burnt.

That the American government in 1937 knew of Amelia and Fred Noonan's capture, but withheld the true story from the public to avoid political embarrassment, and an early conflict with the Japanese in the Pacific for which they were unprepared.

 

Not all of the songs on the album are directly about Amelia Earhart. But the album carries that somber, mellow tone that so much great folk music of the early '70s was in touch with. Many of the songs are about seeing and reaching for light, whether they be the light of day or the light of death. So in a way the album is more about the way people felt about, cared about and thought about Amelia Earhart and her death. That she is still considered a heroine of aviation and a distinctly american hero keeps the mystery of what happened to her in the greater cultural imagination.

plainsong%20gate.JPG

Matthews and mates' album does a great job of melding the more roots style of American folk with his rockier British folk sound on the album, even including a southern gospel tune, "I'll Fly Away." While Matthews has five originals on the album, they all sound perfectly in tune with the covers the band performs.

I think the best cover on the album is of Judy Henske's "Raider." Matthews brings a distinctly British folk vibe to this American's gothic folk tune. It is a near perfect British/American acid folk creation.

Had Plainsong truly lasted as a band, their's no doubt they'd be known as something akin to the British Eagles. But alas, someone's drinking problem (just whose is never mentioned) got in the way, the band argued, broke up, and never toured the album or made another.

In Search Of Amelia Earhart is all we had to go on, until 2002 when the CD with the full album, previously unreleased demos, and work for a second album that was never issued was released.

This album is a truly great find, search for it and you'll be rewarded.

A few samples can be found here.

Much thanks to David at Jive Time who loaned me his personal, pristine, and near-mint copy for the photos.

RSS icon Comments

1

I LOVE this record, I found it a few months ago. So good. It's amazing how many of the "lost gems" from the 60s/70s are actually worth listening to - the cream didn't always rise to the top, or the market was just too crowded or something. That Alan Stivell record you mentioned the other week is really great too - pretty "virtuoso" but that's not always a bad thing.

Have you heard Dorothy Ashby? I found a record by her called the Rubaiyat of Dorothy Ashby that blew my brains out - it's like, pastoral-ish jazz harp w/ amazing Japanese koto playing (both by Ms. Ashby), weird cosmic-religious lyrics, AND these crazyyyy soul beats and basslines. And sonically it's all incredible - those perfect loose 70's drum sounds and a really clean and present vocal w/ some reverb. Every song sounds like something the RZA would sample and have a huge hit with, but in this cool semi-"psychedelic" (boo to that word) context. I was pretty shocked!

Posted by Pecknold | January 7, 2008 5:38 PM
2

That's a neatlooking album cover, almost like Corianton's artwork inside Every Scene Needs a Center.

My hands down fave person from Fairport Convention is Sandy Denny.
Cool post Terry, very grunge.

Posted by GrMkLSk | January 7, 2008 7:35 PM
3

Have you heard Dorothy Ashby?

Yes. Also check out Afro-Harping.

"psychedelic" (boo to that word)

Nah, it's a perfectly fine word. Frequent misuse has cheapened it, but that's not the word's fault.

I was pretty shocked!

Ashby was on Cadet Records--the epitome of psychedelic soul (see Rotary Connection, Ramsey Lewis, Charles Stepney, Phil Upchurch). Get on down to Jive Time or Dusty Groove and catch up, son.


Posted by segal | January 7, 2008 7:58 PM
4

Yeah! Cool cover. Terry always has the best album art.

Posted by trent moorman | January 7, 2008 11:12 PM
5

definitely digging this music. way to mine the gold, terry.

im prepping a story on citay, a band from SF playing the sunset on jan 18. "battle of evermore" by led zep + "fearless" by pink floyd=citay. 70s folk meets 70s metal in a modern studio w a lot of psychedelics. its very california and very, very good.

somehow all this stuff seems related to me.

Posted by jz | January 8, 2008 2:56 PM
6

Well, I just got put in my place.

Posted by Pecknold | January 8, 2008 3:00 PM
7

Nice Terry! I actually never knew the narrative suggestion of that record until you mentioned it, and have gotten it back out since and enjoyed it that much more.

Posted by Dougsf | January 8, 2008 4:31 PM
8

I love pretty much everything this guy has recorded, even the soft rock stuff like "Shake It" which kinda seems creepy when you hear it in the soundtrack for Little Darlings. Any idea why he changed his name to Iain Matthews later on?
Also, dig this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ELVsWYC9_EA

Posted by Eric Shea | January 8, 2008 4:43 PM
9

@6
I apologize for the somewhat grouchy tone of my post, Robin. Most of it was written in the spirit of what I hope was helpful guidance.

Posted by segal | January 8, 2008 8:21 PM
10

Excellent album. Also try Pure & Crooked (1990) and Go For Broke (1976).

I once sat by Mathews at a Sonics game, '79. Nice guy. He lived in Seattle from '78 to '84 and played local bars in the power-pop band Hi Fi with David Surkamp (Pavlov's Dog) and Bruce Hazen, most recently with Billy Moon.

Posted by jiff | January 9, 2008 10:41 AM

After leaving Fairport Convention in 1969, and scoring a UK no.1 with Woodstock the following year, hopes were high for Ian Matthews' new, supposedly permanent outfit Plainsong. In Search of Amelia Earhart was lavished with critical praise on its 1972 release, but its folk-tinged country in clipped Limey tones passed the public by.
 
Tensions during the recording of a second album caused the band to knock it on the head, but the results are gathered here for the first time, more than 30 years later, in the second disc of this terrific package. Plainsong were the closest the UK ever came to producing a rival to the Flying Burrito Brothers, a gloriously harmonic marriage of olde English folk, Appalachian gospel and dustbowl travelogues.
 
It's not often you hear mandolins duelling with wah-wah guitars on the same track, or a traditional tale of northern millworkers preceding a Merle Haggard saloon lament, but Plainsong had no use for rulebooks; they were far too busy crafting intelligent acoustic soundscapes and toying with accepted pop sensibilities, and to be presented with 40 examples of such joyousness in one tidy case is a rare and wonderful thing. Undoubtedly one of the rediscoveries of the year.
Album: Journeys from Gospel Oak
Artist: Ian Matthews
Genre: Folk

Billed as a contractual obligation record by the artist, Journeys from Gospel Oak is easily as good as Matthews' best work. It is most assuredly a companion piece to Plainsong's In Search of Amelia Earhart (an album loosely based on the disappearance of Amelia Earhart), this time loosely based around the night Hank Williams died. This album includes such solid tracks as Gene Clark's "Polly," "Bride 1945" by Paul Siebel, and the haunting Jimmy Webb tune, "Met Her on a Plane." A strong (but often overlooked record) and well worth the effort it takes to find a copy. ~ Jim Worbois, All Music Guide [-] Collapse

After recording two acclaimed solo albums on Vertigo Records, under the sponsorship of former Yardbird Paul Samwell-Smith and surrounded by a who's who of likeminded British semi-folkies (notably another ex-Fairporter, Richard Thompson), he formed Plainsong, who signed to Elektra Records and in 1972 produced In Search of Amelia Earhart, which solidified Matthews' songwriting reputation with the critics, if not with the general public. The album included a cover of Dave McEnery's "Amelia Earhart's Last Flight", plus a song of Matthews' own, "True Story of Amelia Earhart's Last Night" based on the research that suggest that Earhart on her round-the-world flight may have been spying on Japanese bases in the Pacific islands. It also included "Even the Guiding Light", a spiritually positive answer to Thompson’s powerful but bleak "Meet on the Ledge".

[edit] "Bouncing around"

After Plainsong collapsed due to a bandmate's alcohol problem, and with his career now based in Los Angeles, he released several more albums with ad hoc bands, including one produced by ex-Monkee Michael Nesmith (Valley Hi), but none met with commercial success. He bounced from Elektra to CBS Records, to the small Rockburgh label, where he finally scored a hit single in 1978 with a cover of Terence Boylan's "Shake It", which peaked at #13 in the U.S. charts, and a moderately successful follow-up covering Robert Palmer's "Gimme an Inch". However, the North American rights for his album were held by the small Canadian label Mushroom. Label-owner Shelly Siegel, died suddenly in 1979, leaving the label rudderless.

As Matthews' official web site writes, at this point he "had been struggling for nearly 15 years now and was still living hand to mouth, with nothing to show for his efforts but a string of out-of-print albums, and the loyalty of those musicians and fans who shared his vision." [2] He moved from Los Angeles to then-inexpensive Seattle, where he teamed up with David Surkamp, formerly of the St. Louis band Pavlov's Dog, to form the power-pop band Hi-Fi, whose repertoire included Matthews originals, but also covers of Neil Young's "Mr. Soul" and Prince's "When U Were Mine". Neither this nor a return to solo recording in England turned his luck. He worked for a while in an A&R capacity at Island Records and then new-agey Windham Hill Records.

 

 

Back to Bad Cat homepage/search

Back to BadCat reviews

Back to BadCat payment information